After the Pakistan team’s dismal performance in the first half of their World Cup campaign in England, the fans are angry to say the least. The team is being criticized from left, right and center and in both acceptable and unacceptable manners. The Pakistan Cricket Board, like in all the previous world cups where we didn’t live up to the expectations, is feeling the heat and is now looking for scapegoats it seems. As a cricket fan and a supporter of the Pakistan Cricket team, I too, am heartbroken. But what I fail to understand is how the announcement of not renewing Inzamam’s and Mickey Arthur’s contracts and that too while we are still in the middle of the tournament changes things around for Pakistan cricket. I mean, what was the hurry? Did the PCB just succumb to public pressure and sentiment? Where do we go from here? And most importantly for me: didn’t we see this coming?
Let’s look at some historical facts to understand the situation. Inzamam and Mickey Arthur were given their respective responsibilities after the T20 World Cup back in 2016. Some questioned their appointments back then as well. Reasons for the opposition were lack of experience as far as Inzamam was concerned and an excess of bad coaching experiences in the case of Mickey Arthur. Mickey had had forgettable coaching stints with South Africa & Australia, and he had suggested at a time that Pakistan was involved in match fixing in one of the games played between South Africa and Pakistan in 2007. Nevertheless, both Mickey Arthur and Inzamam came on-board with the mission to change things around for Pakistan cricket. But were these two gentlemen enough to make Pakistan reach the top of the mountain? I didn’t think so even then.
Read: Will Mickey Arthur and Inzi be enough?
Pakistan cricket needed revamping which it still does. Players’ fitness was an issue back then as it is right now so clearly that is one department that hasn’t witnessed improvement. The domestic structure is still pretty frail, and you can only see players coming out of the domestic circuit who are either exceptionally talented or very lucky- the system doesn’t seem to be playing a role in developing new players for the national side. A discussion did commence between Younis Khan and the PCB which gave me a glimmer of hope that things might start to change with players like Younis Khan working at the grassroot level but even that didn’t materialize as I wrote in my previous blog.
Read: Younis Khan and PCB couldn’t reach an agreement – whose loss is it?
Where we are today did not happen overnight and we cannot just blame two people for it, especially now. If you take a look at the records, T20s have been the only format of the game where the Pakistan team has done well after the T20 World Cup in 2016. Since the T20 World Cup, the team has only lost 2 T20 series out of the 13 that they have played which includes a Tri-Series as well. The 2 losses also came very recently at the hands of South Africa and England. Other than T20s, the Pakistan team’s performance graph has consistently been spelling out bad news for them over the last 3 years.
In test matches, we have only won 4 out of the 11 test series played under the coaching of Mickey Arthur. That makes for a winning percentage (in series) of only 36%. In ODIs, we have won 6 out of the 14 ODI series in which the teams were selected by Inzamam-ul-Haq (Champions Trophy 2017 included). Since 2018, we have only won 1 ODI series (out of 6) and that too against Zimbabwe.
If any action that could’ve resulted in visible improvement was to be taken, it should’ve been taken earlier. If it wasn’t taken then, then it doesn’t really make a difference taking it now. In fact, taking the announcement in the midst of the tournament has sent out a very wrong message to the team management & the team which is anything but good for their morale. The need of the hour is to show maturity and support towards the side that we have sent for the mega event and take necessary actions after the event concludes (regardless of the team’s performance from here on). What has led us to this stage is the practice of sweeping our weaknesses under the mat after a one-off spark of brilliance put on display by the team once in a blue moon. This practice should now stop, and a root cause analysis needs to be carried out to not only identify the main areas of problem but to solve them diligently too.
We are a nation that loves cricket unconditionally, lets continue to give that love and support to our side in their difficult times too while preparing ourselves to take some concrete steps to improve the cricketing system in the country for better and consistent results.
-Hammad A. Mateen